Pro Tips

College Sports Ticket Sales: A Practical Fan Follow-Up Plan

College Sports Ticket Sales: A Practical Fan Follow-Up Plan

Improve college sports ticket sales with a practical fan follow-up plan for past buyers, season renewals, calls, texts, and staff handoffs.

Jesse Wisnewski

CEO & Founder

Published

Read Time

7 min read

Your ticket office has last season’s buyer list. Some fans bought a single game. Others had season tickets or attended with a group. You know the next schedule, but your staff can’t call everyone.

Better college sports ticket sales can start with better follow-up, not another promotion. Reach out with a relevant reason to return. Give fans accurate information and a simple way to ask for help.

Calls, texts, and email can work together when permissions are clear. The goal isn’t to promise a sellout. It’s to help more interested fans take the next step while keeping ticket staff available for real conversations.

In this post, I’m going to cover:

  • Which past buyers to contact first

  • A simple fan follow-up campaign

  • When to use calls, text, email, or AI voice

  • What Toledo and Ohio State show about fan service

  • How to measure the results

Why follow-up matters for college sports ticket sales

A past buyer isn’t the same as a stranger. They already know your team and venue. But you may not know why they haven’t bought again.

Maybe the schedule changed. Maybe they need different seats, help with a group purchase, or clearer information. Don’t assume they’re uninterested.

Sending every past buyer the same urgent offer won’t solve those problems. Ask what each group needs to take a next step. Your ticketing system records purchases and inventory. Your follow-up process helps people act on that information.

Four fan groups to contact first

Start with purchase history you’re allowed to use. Build a few groups with different needs. Then give each group a useful invitation, not a guess about their finances or loyalty.

1. Season-ticket holders near renewal

Share the correct deadline, seat information, payment steps, and available options. Show fans how to renew, change plans, or speak with someone. This is a service reminder, not a cold sales pitch.

2. Past single-game buyers

A fan who attended one matchup may want to return for a similar game. Share the verified schedule or offer an invitation. Don’t assume you know their favorite opponent or budget.

3. Group buyers and community partners

Schools, youth teams, alumni chapters, and local businesses may need group seats or help with logistics. Ask whether they’d like information. Give complex requests to a ticket staff member.

4. Fans with an unanswered question

Someone who asked about seating, parking, or a premium experience has already shown a specific need. Answer that question first. Stop generic reminders once a staff member takes over.

These groups are easier to serve than one giant list. The group shapes the invitation. The response decides what happens next.

A six-step fan follow-up campaign

Choose one game or renewal window. Confirm the ticket details with your staff before you write anything. Then build a clear path from invitation to response.

  1. Choose the goal. Renew a package, request group details, purchase an eligible seat, or speak with ticket staff.

  2. Build the list. Check past purchases, contact details, permissions, and opt-outs.

  3. Write the invitation. Include accurate game details and an official purchase route. Don’t promise discounts or seats you can’t guarantee.

  4. Plan for replies. Decide what happens after a yes, a question, no response, a decline, or an opt-out.

  5. Assign staff. Route complex seating, accessibility, payment, and donor-benefit questions to the right person.

  6. Update the record. Log the outcome and stop purchase reminders after a confirmed sale.

Here’s an illustrative email to a past single-game buyer:

Sample email: “Hi [First name], thanks for joining us at [Game] last season. The [Team] schedule is out, including [verified matchup/date]. Would you like ticket details or help choosing an option? Our ticket office is happy to help.”

It works because it refers to a real past visit and offers help. Once that person buys or replies, the next message should change.

Choose the right channel for each conversation

Don’t repeat the same request across calls, texts, and email. Let each channel do what it does best.

  • Email: Game details, seating information, and longer explanations.

  • Text: A short, permitted link or requested reminder.

  • Staff call: Group packages, accessibility needs, premium seats, and donor questions.

  • AI voice: May fit a narrow, legally reviewed invitation or event reminder when consent and disclosure requirements are met.

AI voice should never pretend to be a student or employee. It should not invent seat availability, negotiate prices, or handle complex account concerns. The FCC’s 2024 AI voice ruling explains why artificial and prerecorded voice rules matter. Have qualified counsel review each campaign.

For athletics teams already using separate ticketing systems, EverRaise university engagement workflows can support reviewed voice, text, and email outreach. The Campaign Builder helps prepare messages for a defined audience. It doesn’t manage seats or process payments.

For more context, read our AI outbound calling guide or phonathon software guide. Human staff still own the relationship and the next step.

Two real lessons from Toledo and Ohio State

These examples show what reliable fan service requires. They aren’t proof that a software tool increased ticket sales.

Toledo: Give fans a named contact

In October 2026, the University of Toledo announced its Rocket Account Manager program. Eligible season-ticket members and Rocket Fund donors were assigned a representative for tickets, renewals, game-day planning, and other needs.

The lesson is simple. A fan should know whom to contact. An automated invitation is more useful when a real person can answer the next question.

Ohio State: Get the ticket details right

Ohio State’s football ticket information lists renewal deadlines, eligibility rules, and steps for seat changes. Those details matter when you’re preparing outreach.

Don’t send an outdated renewal date or imply a seat guarantee. Accurate ticket operations come first. Follow-up should help fans understand the actual offer.

When should a person handle the conversation?

Before you automate, ask four questions:

  • Is the message’s purpose narrow and clear?

  • Are the likely answers predictable?

  • What happens if the information is wrong?

  • Can a fan quickly reach a real person?

A game reminder may pass that test. A premium-seat dispute or major-donor conversation probably won’t.

Let ticket representatives handle established relationships and complex group requests. Structured outreach can help send approved details and identify fans who want staff assistance. Its job is to support service, not eliminate the staff who provide it.

How to measure fan follow-up

Don’t stop at calls placed, emails sent, or links clicked. Focus on what fans actually did next.

  • Eligible buyers contacted

  • Meaningful replies and ticket inquiries

  • Staff handoffs completed

  • Confirmed purchases and renewals

  • Opt-outs and complaints

For a test with 200 eligible past buyers, track each stage separately. Who received a permitted message? Who asked for information? Who completed a purchase in the ticketing system?

A purchase after outreach doesn’t prove the outreach caused it. Compare similar groups or periods, accounting for opponent, price, and inventory. I’d rather see a small campaign with useful replies than a big campaign measured only by attempts.

Common questions about ticket sales outreach

Can AI voice help colleges sell tickets?

It may help with a narrow, approved reminder or invitation. It can’t guarantee a sale. Pricing, seat, account, and donor questions still need staff judgment.

What’s the best way to reach past buyers?

Start with a verified past interaction and a relevant reason to return. Offer accurate ticket information and a clear way to speak with someone.

Should phone and text follow-up work together?

They can, when permitted. Let each response control the next message. Once someone buys, send logistics instead of another sales pitch. Honor opt-outs.

Make the next fan interaction easier

Pick one fan group. Verify the offer. Send a clear invitation and give meaningful replies an owner. That small process can show you where buyers need more help.

If you’d like to test approved outreach around your existing ticket records, request an EverRaise demo. Your athletics team stays responsible for the relationship and transaction.

EverRaise

Empowering nonprofits to build lasting relationships through intelligent, automated engagement.

© 2025 EverRaise. All rights reserved.

EverRaise

Empowering nonprofits to build lasting relationships through intelligent, automated engagement.

© 2025 EverRaise. All rights reserved.