A practical guide to building accurate LYBUNT and SYBUNT donor lists, choosing the right follow-up, and measuring what happens next.

Jesse Wisnewski
CEO & Founder
Published
Read Time
9 min read

You open your donor database and find several hundred people who gave before but have not made a gift this year. Are they truly lapsed? Are some waiting for December? Has someone already renewed a gift under a different record?
That is what LYBUNT and SYBUNT reports help you investigate. They identify past donors who haven’t given in the current reporting period so that you can build a more thoughtful follow-up plan. But a report is a starting point, not a verdict on a person’s loyalty.
If this is new to you, let’s cut to the chase:
LYBUNT means “Last Year But Unfortunately Not This Year.”
SYBUNT means “Some Year But Unfortunately Not This Year.”
The first looks at people who gave in the year immediately preceding this one. The second looks at people who gave in any earlier year but not the current one. In a typical report, LYBUNT donors are also part of the broader SYBUNT group.
A useful donor reactivation plan starts with accurate definitions, then figuring out what each person actually needs. You do not need to send the same appeal to every name.
In this post, I’m going to cover:
The difference between LYBUNT and SYBUNT, with examples
How to build and clean the lists in your donor database
How to prioritize messages and staff follow-up
What to measure before and after a small reactivation test
Let’s dig in.
What is a LYBUNT report?
A LYBUNT report lists donors who gave in the previous year but have not given in the current year or comparison period. Fundraising teams use it to find supporters who may be due for an invitation, an impact update, or a personal check-in.
For example, suppose your team is reviewing 2026 giving on November 18. Maria gave in December 2025 but has not given in 2026. She appears on a calendar-year LYBUNT list. That doesn’t necessarily mean she’s stopped supporting you. Her usual gift may arrive in December.
A database needs clear date rules to produce a useful list. Little Green Light’s documentation shows both a LYBUNT report template and the search criteria needed to recreate it. Your own CRM may use different labels or a fiscal-year setting.
What is a SYBUNT report?
A SYBUNT report finds people who gave in some prior year but not the current one. It is a wider pool that can include last year’s donors and people whose last gifts were several years ago. The Bloomerang glossary explains how the two reports support different donor reengagement decisions.
Imagine Joseph gave in 2022 and 2024, then made no gifts in 2025 or 2026. He is SYBUNT in 2026 but not LYBUNT, because he did not give during 2025. His relationship may need a different opening than Maria’s, especially if your team has had no recent conversation with him.
If you plan one campaign for recent lapses and another for older ones, make those lists exclusive. Build your recent group from LYBUNT donors, then remove them from the older SYBUNT group. Otherwise, someone may receive both campaigns.
How LYBUNT and SYBUNT lists differ
These terms describe giving history, not someone’s motivation. Use the comparison to decide which records to investigate first.
Report | Giving history | What to check |
|---|---|---|
LYBUNT | Gave during the immediately prior year; has not yet given in the current period | Check expected giving month, recent conversations, and first-year versus repeat donor status. |
SYBUNT | Gave in at least one earlier year; has not yet given this period | Separate recent lapses from donors absent for several years and look for an appropriate reconnection. |
Neither report tells you whether a payment failed, a donor changed names, a household made a gift under another record, or someone asked to be removed from outreach. Those details matter more than the acronym.
How to build accurate LYBUNT and SYBUNT lists
Start with a small test of the rules rather than exporting everyone and assuming the file is correct. You can build a useful list from two gift-date filters, but exceptions determine whether it is safe to use.
1. Fix the reporting period
Decide whether you are using calendar years or your organization’s fiscal year. Write the exact dates beside the report. If your fiscal year runs July through June, a November report may count donors very differently from one based on January through December.
For an as-of comparison, consider the same portion of each year as well as the full-year list. Someone who gives only at year-end should not be treated like someone who normally gives every February. Explain the rule in the campaign brief so the team does not mistake a seasonal giver for a lost one.
2. Use gift history rather than the date a record was created
For LYBUNT, include donors with at least one qualifying gift in the prior-year window and no qualifying gift in the current comparison window. For SYBUNT, include donors with a qualifying gift before the current period and none within it.
Check how your system handles recurring gifts, unpaid pledges, in-kind gifts, matched gifts, refunds, soft credits, and household records. Those definitions vary across organizations. A supporter whose contribution is recorded under a spouse’s name might otherwise appear lapsed incorrectly.
3. Add the information staff need to act
Export donor ID, last valid gift date, number of lifetime gifts, last giving amount, usual giving month, assigned staff member, last contact, communication preferences, and any relevant response notes. Include a field showing why each record was selected.
Keep only the data the staff need for the approved campaign. Store exports securely, limit access, and do not move private donor information into an unapproved tool.
4. Remove records that should not receive the campaign
Before contacting anyone, check suppressions, duplicate records, deceased constituents, staff-managed major-gift relationships, active recurring plans, open donor-service issues, and prior requests to stop communication. A payment problem should go to donor services, not a generic “we miss you” appeal.
Little Green Light’s basic filtering guide gives an example of using last-gift dates and gift types for a classic LYBUNT search. Whatever system you use, manually inspect a handful of included and excluded records before your first send.
Who should receive follow-up first?
Not every name deserves the same message or level of staff attention. I would first sort the clean list by recent giving history, relationship owner, and whether the usual giving date has passed. Then use a small number of practical groups.
Recently missed an expected gift
A repeat donor who typically gives every spring but missed this spring is a good candidate for a warm check-in. Mention the specific mission or program they supported when that information is accurate. Do not assume financial hardship, disinterest, or a decision to stop giving.
Usually gives at year-end
A donor who gave in December 2025 may not have given yet by November 2026. Start with a timely update or year-end invitation rather than a message that says they have disappeared. Treat the person’s normal pattern as part of the data.
Older lapsed donor with a long history
A donor who once supported your work for several years may deserve a personal conversation. If a fundraiser owns the relationship, route the name to that person before sending a general appeal. Ask what they remember about the work and whether they would like an update.
One-time donor who never made a second gift
This person may need an introduction to what happened after their first contribution. Share one credible result of the work and explain how they can stay connected. A second-gift request may be appropriate later, but don’t pretend a long-time relationship already exists.
The current retention problem is real. In its October 29, 2026 report on FEP’s second-quarter findings, the Association of Fundraising Professionals reported that dollars were up 6.6% year over year while donor counts were down 1.6%. That is a sector-level, year-to-date estimate, not evidence that a specific LYBUNT campaign will raise more money.
A simple donor reactivation plan for one small segment
A useful first test is a group of about 50 eligible LYBUNT donors with a similar giving history and no staff-owned conversation in progress. Fifty is an illustrative starting size, not a benchmark. Choose a group your team can actually follow up with.
First contact: lead with recognition
Use a message like this, edited for the real donor and your organization:
Subject: A quick update from [Organization]
Hi [First name], thank you for supporting [specific program] last year. I wanted to share a short update about [verified impact or milestone]. We are grateful for the part you played. If you would like to hear more about what’s ahead, here is [relevant update].
This is a stewardship message, not an assertion that the donor has lapsed. Confirm the prior gift and impact claim before personalizing it.
Second contact: offer one meaningful next step
If you have not heard back after a reasonable interval, and the person remains eligible for follow-up, invite them to attend a briefing, read an impact report, or reconnect with a staff member. A giving invitation can be part of the sequence, but it should fit the relationship and campaign purpose.
For calls or text messages, confirm channel-specific permission, disclosures, restrictions, and opt-out practices before sending. A donor’s phone number in the CRM is not automatically permission to use AI voice or SMS.
Human handoff: do not let replies disappear
Create three simple response categories: wants information, wants a conversation, and does not want further contact. Assign an owner and a due date for every response that needs attention. The most important failure to avoid is asking donors to reply and then leaving their reply unanswered.
EverRaise’s engagement tools describe coordinated, reviewed voice, SMS, email, and staff follow-up. If you are considering that approach, verify which capabilities are active for your account and let your team approve every audience and message. The donor relationship remains your responsibility.
If you need a deeper general framework beyond report definitions, see EverRaise’s lapsed donor reactivation guide and donor stewardship guide. This article’s purpose is narrower: finding the right names, using the right reporting window, and deciding what to do next.
What should you measure?
Measure the list and the relationship, not only immediate donations. Keep a record of the original eligible population, how many people were suppressed, how many received approved outreach, how many responded, and how many staff follow-ups were completed.
If 50 eligible records produce 8 responses and your team completes 6 of the 8 requested follow-ups, the completion rate is 75%. That is a made-up planning example, not an EverRaise result. Count future gifts separately and compare them over a sensible period, being careful about seasonal giving.
For a cleaner organization-wide view, pair these results with a consistent donor retention calculation. LYBUNT and SYBUNT are useful working lists, but they do not replace a well-defined annual retention rate.
The goal is to reconnect, not simply to remove names from a report
A LYBUNT or SYBUNT report helps you find relationships that may need attention. It cannot tell you why someone hasn’t given this year, and it shouldn’t write the entire story for you.
Start with accurate dates. Check the unusual records. Choose one meaningful group and a message that respects its history. Then make sure someone follows through when a donor responds.
If you want to explore how approved voice, text, email, and staff follow-up can work together, you can request an EverRaise demo and bring one real, privacy-safe campaign scenario to review.

